If you always make the textbook call as a coach you will never catch your opponent by surprise. You will likely get outcoached by your opponent because you make it easy to anticipate your moves and appropriately prepare, plan, and/or counter them.
There is value in knowing general recommendations for specific situations, so I’m not saying to throw the “textbook” out altogether. However, sticking with what “should” be done in every situation every time gets a) very boring and b) very predictable. Neither is what you’re striving for is it?
When people ask me what should I call in “this” situation, I really can’t give them an answer. I can give a general answer given general guidelines, but there is so much more to consider than the number of outs, the score, the count, and so on.
Honestly, in my opinion, making coaching calls comes down to doing the best you can with the information you have and trusting your gut (not only your head). Yes you will make the wrong call from time to time, but that happens to every coach. It’s highly unlikely you will make every right call every single time regardless of the decision making method you choose. So why not make the one you feel strongest about?
In any given situation there are various calls that could possibly give you an outcome you desire. There’s more than one way to skin the cat you’re after, in other words.
However, as a coach, you can only choose one option and have only a limited amount of time to make that choice. I believe, the more you make the call your gut tells you to (after evaluating the situation the best you can with the information you have), the more you learn and the better you get at it.
Sometimes, even with a great call, the ball still doesn’t bounce your way. Other times you simply blow a call. Then there are times you make a call you shouldn’t have and it all works out just fine, or better.
Regardless of how things shake out, the bottom line is you need to…
- Do YOUR best in that time and place to make a decision based upon the information you DO have
- Make the call you can stand behind even if it doesn’t work out (aka go with your gut)
- Learn from the situation regardless of the outcome
So yes, you can study to your heart’s content, but in the end, make the call that’s really tugging at you, jumping up and down, waving it’s hands in the air, and calling out to you. If it goes great, file that piece of information away for the future. If it goes terribly, file that piece of information away for the future.
It’s when you have no method to your madness and just try things just for the heck of it (and on top of that don’t bother to learn from the situation either way) that you never make any real progress or get better at making the best softball coaching decisions for your team.
The last thing you want to be saying after a game is, “I knew I should’ve done this, but the ‘right’ call is _____, so I went with that.” You’ll just keep beating yourself up because you had a feeling you should make a certain call, but since it’s not what most people would do, you played it safe and made the more traditional call that people would expect. That way you don’t get blamed for making a “bad” call since you made the “right” decision coaches are “supposed to” make.
I’d rather be able to look back at a decision and say, “I made the best choice I could in that time and place and really believed it would work, but today it didn’t. Now I know X, Y, and Z and will make a better decision in the future.”
Any time something doesn’t work out, there will be people who will say you made a “bad call.” That comes with the territory. Like I said before, sometimes it’s not the call. Sometimes things just don’t work out. Newsflash: You can’t control outcomes! You can only control your process. Did you make the best evaluation you could and make your best decision based upon that? If so, you’re process what right. Things just didn’t bounce your way. That’s not in your control.
If not, then there was something in your process that wasn’t right. Could be what information you gathered to make the decision. Could be how you interpreted the information to make your decision. Could just be your decision.
Whatever the case, instead of looking at the only the call itself, also remember to look at the process that led to the call. Sometimes there is something there that can be fixed for the future. Other times, it just wasn’t meant to be. Other times it was flat out a bad call. You need to be able to look back, evaluate your process and see where you can get better. Your learning needs to go beyond just the “textbook.”



One thing I’m really picky about as a coach is seeing players make good choices. I’m not only talking about where to throw the ball, but about how they approach the game and the small decisions they make on a daily basis.
I think free advice comes with the territory when it comes to softball coaching. Sometimes it seems that everyone and their mother has an opinion – literally. One word of caution when taking free advice…sometimes it’s worth what you paid for it. Nothing.